Billing and Claims


We’d always prefer to speak with you directly but if you can’t reach us and need to make a payment or urgently report a claim, please find your insurance company information below to call or click the link to visit their website:

Pekin Insurance   Billing 800-322-0160 x2010    Claims  800-735-4611

Grange Insurance   Billing  800-422-0550   Claims  800-445-3030

Safeco Insurance   Billing  888-723-3260  Claims  800-332-3226

Western Reserve Group  Billing 877-566-0699  Claims 800-362-0426

State Auto  Billing  800-444-9950  Claims 800-766-1853

Travelers  Billing  800-842-5075  Claims 800-252-4633

Encompass  Billing   Claims 800-588-7400

Progressive  Billing  800-876-5581  Claims 800-274-4499

Nationwide/Allied  Billing  800-282-1446 Claims  800-282-1446

Liberty Mutual Commercial  Billing 800-290-2920  Claims 800-362-0000

Pike Mutual  Billing 330-345-2005  Claims  330-345-2005

Hagerty  Billing  888-220-9565  Claims 888-220-9565

If your current company is unlisted, please call us directly 740-966-3180 to make payment arrangements or report a claim. As mentioned above, we would always prefer you go through our agency to make your payments and report any claims. Most of the company claim numbers are answered 24/7 so you could reach them even when our office is closed. If you are unsure where to call and you need an urgent response, call Alison Speck on her cell 740-404-5719 and leave a message.


Request Your Proposal Here

Are you ready to save time, aggravation, and money? The team at MVP Insurance is here and ready to make the process as painless as possible. We look forward to meeting you!